
Location: Indianapolis, IN
Services: Cedar siding repair, full-house exterior painting, trim replacement, built-in gutter replacement, Pella Reserve window replacement, Malarkey roof replacement, GAF TPO low-slope roof installation, Velux skylight installation
Customer Question: Who Can Restore a Historic Indianapolis Home Exterior?
This homeowner needed a trusted exterior contractor for a traditional 1890s home in a historic Indianapolis neighborhood. The three-story home featured wood siding, decorative mouldings, trim details, and the character homeowners want to preserve in older Indianapolis properties.
The concerns were not limited to appearance. The home had leaking windows, rotted cedar siding, leaking gutters, and roof leaks. They needed a contractor who could handle multiple exterior issues while respecting the home’s historic details.

Why the Homeowner Chose JD Hostetter
They chose JD Hostetter because of the experience, communication, options, customer service, design assistance, and clarity offered throughout the process. The homeowner also needed a full-service exterior restoration team that could help guide a complex project from planning through completion.
The consultation process included:
- An initial meeting to discuss the project scope
- A second meeting to review design changes, budget, and samples
- A final meeting to confirm selections, contract details, and deposit
Services Performed for This Indianapolis Historic Home

JD Hostetter completed a full exterior restoration that addressed the home’s water intrusion, wood rot, and aging materials. The work included siding repair, a full-house paint project, trim replacement, built-in gutter system replacement, new Pella Reserve windows, a new Malarkey roof, a GAF TPO low-slope roof system, and Velux skylights.
Materials replaced included rotted trim, soffit, cedar siding, windows, and roofing. New materials included matching cedar lap siding, Pella windows, Malarkey roofing, GAF TPO flat roofing, and Velux skylights. The final color palette included cream, red, and green to complement the home’s historic character.
Project Process and Historic Home Challenges
This project required more than standard exterior replacement. The home needed major wood repairs, and the scope involved IHPC requirements. JD Hostetter helped navigate conversations with IHPC and assisted in securing approval for the work.
During the project, a car fire damaged the garage. JD Hostetter helped the homeowner navigate the insurance process and incorporated those repairs into the ongoing work. The team also helped find a masonry contractor to repair the chimney efficiently with a long-term solution.
Results for This Indianapolis Exterior Restoration
The finished project restored the home’s protection, function, and curb appeal while preserving its historic look. The homeowner said they “absolutely loved it” and “couldn’t be happier.” He also appreciated our project manager’s communication and our team’s help with the window replacement.
For homeowners with an older Indianapolis home that needs siding repair, window replacement, roofing, gutters, or full exterior restoration, JD Hostetter provides a clear process and experienced guidance from start to finish. Contact JD Hostetter to schedule your free estimate.










