• Siding
    • James Hardie Siding
    • Fiber Cement Siding
    • Vinyl Siding
  • Roofing
    • Asphalt Shingles
    • Hail & Storm Damage Roof Repair
    • The Homeowner’s Complete Roofing Guide
  • Windows
    • Pella Windows
  • Painting
  • Gutters
    • Gutter Guards
  • Projects
    • Featured Projects
    • Gallery
  • About Us
    • Awards & Affiliations
    • Financing
    • Resources
      • Blog
      • James Hardie Siding Guide
      • Replacement Windows Buying Guide
      • Homeowner’s Complete Roofing Guide
      • James Hardie vs. Vinyl Siding
      • Media
    • Reviews
    • Video Resources
    • Areas We Serve
    • Contact Us
  • Special Offers
  • Referral Program
  • Get a Free Estimate

JD Hostetter

Mobile Menu
(317) 517-7847
FREE ESTIMATE
  • Services +
    • Siding +
      • James Hardie Siding
      • Fiber Cement Siding
      • Vinyl Siding
    • Roofing +
      • Asphalt Shingles
      • Hail & Storm Damage Roof Repair
      • Homeowner’s Complete Roofing Guide
    • Windows +
      • Pella Windows
    • Painting
    • Gutters +
      • Gutter Guards
  • Areas We Serve
  • Projects +
    • Featured Projects
    • Gallery
  • About Us +
    • Awards & Affiliations
    • Financing
    • Resources +
      • Blog
      • Replacement Windows Buying Guide
      • The Homeowner’s Complete Roofing Guide
      • James Hardie Siding Guide
      • James Hardie Vs. Vinyl Siding
      • Video Resources
      • Media
    • Special Offers
    • Referral Program
    • Reviews
    • Contact Us
Home » Resources & Blog » Guide to Replacement Siding Options

Guide to Replacement Siding Options

June 27, 2017
Updated on April 18, 2023

Tom Pantzer

guide-to-replacement-siding-optionsIt’s time to replace your home siding. Perhaps your old siding has seen better days, or you are in the mood for something new, transforming the look of your house.

But what kind of replacement siding should you choose to protect your home from the elements and to give it a striking visual appeal?

When you speak to your friendly neighborhood siding contractor, they will lead through your options, giving you the pros and cons for each. They would include:

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding is still the most popular home siding in the United States. It’s available in many different colors and styles, lightweight, easy to install (even over existing siding) and modestly priced. It’s also durable, requires little maintenance and will keep its shape even under extreme temperatures.

As far as drawbacks, overlapping panels will sometimes show seams and the same ingredient that makes vinyl durable, PVC, doesn’t degrade in landfills and can yield toxins.

Fiber Cement Siding

Fiber cement siding has steadily risen in popularity since the 1990s. Composed of a mixture of cement, sand, and cellulose that’s toughened using pressurized steam, fiber-cement siding is aimed at homeowners who want the look of wood without the associated problems and maintenance costs.

Fiber-cement replacement siding is more durable than wood, non-combustible, water-resistant, bug-resistant and often comes with a 50-year warranty. You don’t need to paint this home siding, but it is easy to do so if you ever want to change colors

However, fiber cement is heavy, requiring special installation tools, which may add to its cost. The production of Portland cement is said to yield C02 emissions, which may be offset by fiber cement’s long life.

Wood Siding

This once-popular choice has declined substantially over the years and now only commands a small percentage of the home siding market. Even so, there’s something to be said for the natural beauty of wood shown through a clear or semi-transparent stain.

Wood siding comes in many species and grades and can be an expensive option, depending on your choice. If you use an opaque stain then you can select a less-expensive wood siding.

Wood is easy to cut, shape and install, and with regular maintenance can last a century or more. But that’s the catch, it does require maintenance: a clear finish every two years, or re-staining every three years, or repainting every five.

As far as its green factor, wood is, of course, easily biodegradable in landfills. The environmentally conscious can check that the wood replacement siding does not come from an old-growth forest, with a FSC designation that indicates it was sourced in sustainable forests.

Schedule a free siding consultation from the professionals of JD Hostetter & Associates, Indianapolis area’s quality replacement siding company.

Blog Categories

  • Exterior Remodeling
  • Featured Projects
  • Home Improvement
  • James Hardie Siding
  • Painting
  • Pella Windows
  • Roofing
  • Siding
  • Testimonials
  • Uncategorized
  • Videos
  • Windows

Recent Posts

  • How Long Does a Roof Replacement Take? Timeline and Prep Tips for Indianapolis Homeowners

    How Long Does a Roof Replacement Take? Timeline and Prep Tips for Indianapolis Homeowners

    August 19, 2026
  • The Best Window Frame Materials for Indiana’s Changing Seasons

    The Best Window Frame Materials for Indiana’s Changing Seasons

    July 15, 2026
  • How to Coordinate a Full Exterior Remodel Smoothly

    How to Coordinate a Full Exterior Remodel Smoothly

    June 11, 2026

Recent Articles

How Can I Update My Indiana Home to a Modern or Contemporary Style?

How Can I Update My Indiana Home to a Modern or Contemporary Style?

If you’ve considered remodeling the exterior of your Indiana home, you’ve probably looked into both the modern and contemporary designs.   Although these designs are both…
READ MORE
hiring-Siding-Contractor-warning-signs

6 Warning Signs When Hiring a Siding Contractor

If it’s time to replace or repair your siding, then one of the first steps is identifying a short list of local Indianapolis siding contractors…
READ MORE
trending siding replacement in indianapolis

Trending Home Exterior Design Ideas to Incorporate in 2023

If you’re building a new home this year or are considering an exterior remodeling project, there’s a good chance you’d like your home to blend…
READ MORE
JD Hostetter & Associates

We proudly serve Carmel and all of Greater Indianapolis including Fishers, Noblesville, Avon, Greenwood, Plainfield, Zionsville, Westfield

Copyright © 2026 JD Hostetter | Privacy Policy | StructureM

JD Hostetter & Associates | 7651 88th St. W | Indianapolis, IN 46278 | (317) 517-7847

Accessibility Adjustments

Powered by OneTap

Accessibility Commitment for JD Hostetter & Associates

At JD Hostetter & Associates, we are committed to making our digital presence as accessible and inclusive as reasonably possible for all users, including individuals with disabilities. Our goal is to improve the usability of https://jdhostetter.com and to support a more accessible experience for everyone, regardless of their abilities or the technologies they use.

Our Approach to Accessibility

We aim to align with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which define internationally recognized standards for digital accessibility. While full compliance cannot always be guaranteed, we strive to implement improvements where feasible and regularly review accessibility-related aspects of our website. Accessibility is an ongoing process, and we are committed to improving the experience over time as technologies, standards, and user needs evolve.

Accessibility Features

To support accessibility, https://jdhostetter.com may utilize tools such as the OneTap accessibility toolbar. This interface provides users with a range of helpful features, including:
  • Adjustable text size and contrast settings
  • Highlighting of links and text for better visibility
  • Full keyboard navigation of the toolbar interface
  • Quick launch via keyboard shortcut: Alt + . (Windows) or ⌘ + . (Mac)
Please note the following:
  • The availability and effectiveness of these features depend on the website's configuration and ongoing maintenance.
  • While we strive to ensure accessibility, we cannot guarantee that every part of https://jdhostetter.com will be fully accessible at all times. Some content may be provided by third parties or affected by technical constraints beyond our immediate control.

Feedback and Contact

We welcome your feedback. If you experience any accessibility barriers or have suggestions for improvement, please contact us: Email: info@structurem.com We are committed to reviewing all inquiries and aim to respond within 3–5 business days. If you require assistance accessing any part of this website, we are happy to provide support through alternative channels upon request. Last updated: July 30, 2026
How long do you want to hide the toolbar?
Hide Toolbar Duration
Select your accessibility profile
Vision Impaired Mode
Enhances website's visuals
Seizure Safe Profile
Clear flashes & reduces color
ADHD Friendly Mode
Focused browsing, distraction-free
Blindness Mode
Reduces distractions, improves focus
Epilepsy Safe Mode
Dims colors and stops blinking
Content Modules
Font Size

Default

Line Height

Default

Color Modules
Orientation Modules